Skip Nav

Cory Booker’s Senate rules drama, explained

Site Contents

❶Other joint committees serve to make advisory reports; for example, there exists a Joint Committee on Taxation. Senate Curator Historical Library.

Navigation menu

Choose a video to embed
Custom menu

Booker releasing the information was no different from releasing classified information, Cornyn said. After this exchange, White House principal deputy press secretary Raj Shah tweeted a reference to the rules of the Senate, rules that Cornyn read during the hearing: During the hearing, Booker colleagues Richard J. Senate Minority Leader Charles E. This is mostly political melodrama. No senator has been expelled from that body since , and most of the 15 who have been expelled were ousted for expressing support for the Confederacy.

Most of the more recent inquiries into expelling members have resulted in either no action or resignations. Those were for more-traditional offenses: They may very well face some form of punishment, such as censure, but the likelihood of removal is very low. The melodrama that played out Thursday that focused on the release of the already-cleared documents was itself the point.

Expulsion is the most serious consequence a senator can face, and few do. The net result is that Booker got what he wanted — release of information he saw as incriminating — with the most likely result even if he had violated the rules being the equivalent of a write-up from your boss. And, as Cornyn pointedly noted, Booker's stock with a Democratic base champing at the bit for partisan confrontation gained a few points.

This article was updated with the statements from Burck and Booker's office and throughout to reflect the new information. Politics Analysis Analysis Interpretation of the news based on evidence, including data, as well as anticipating how events might unfold based on past events.

Past efforts to expel members of the Senate. The story must be told. Bitter Senate fight to confirm Kavanaugh plunges deeper into chaos over letter. Trump creates political storm with false claim on Puerto Rico hurricane death toll. Analysis Winners and losers of the primary season.

Analysis The Daily However, the right to unlimited debate is generally preserved. Within the United States, the Senate is sometimes referred to as "world's greatest deliberative body". The filibuster is a tactic used to defeat bills and motions by prolonging debate indefinitely.

A filibuster may entail long speeches, dilatory motions, and an extensive series of proposed amendments. The Senate may end a filibuster by invoking cloture. In current practice, the threat of filibuster is more important than its use; almost any motion that does not have the support of three-fifths of the Senate effectively fails. This means that 41 senators can make a filibuster happen. Historically, cloture has rarely been invoked because bipartisan support is usually necessary to obtain the required supermajority , so a bill that already has bipartisan support is rarely subject to threats of filibuster.

However, motions for cloture have increased significantly in recent years. If the Senate invokes cloture, debate does not end immediately; instead, it is limited to 2 additional hours unless increased by another three-fifths vote. The longest filibuster speech in the Senate's history was delivered by Strom Thurmond , who spoke for over 24 hours in an unsuccessful attempt to block the passage of the Civil Rights Act of Under certain circumstances, the Congressional Budget Act of provides for a process called " reconciliation " by which Congress can pass bills related to the budget without those bills being subject to a filibuster.

This is accomplished by limiting all Senate floor debate to 20 hours. When debate concludes, the motion in question is put to a vote. The Senate often votes by voice vote. The presiding officer then announces the result of the voice vote.

A senator, however, may challenge the presiding officer's assessment and request a recorded vote. The request may be granted only if it is seconded by one-fifth of the senators present. In practice, however, senators second requests for recorded votes as a matter of courtesy.

When a recorded vote is held, the clerk calls the roll of the Senate in alphabetical order; senators respond when their name is called. Senators who were not in the chamber when their name was called may still cast a vote so long as the voting remains open. The vote is closed at the discretion of the presiding officer, but must remain open for a minimum of 15 minutes.

A majority of those voting determines whether the motion carries. If the vice president is not present, the motion fails. Filibustered bills require a three-fifths majority to overcome the cloture vote which usually means 60 votes and get to the normal vote where a simple majority usually 51 votes approves the bill. This has caused some news media to confuse the 60 votes needed to overcome a filibuster with the 51 votes needed to approve a bill, with for example USA Today erroneously stating " The vote was in favor of the provision establishing concealed carry permit reciprocity in the 48 states that have concealed weapons laws.

That fell two votes short of the 60 needed to approve the measure ". On occasion, the Senate may go into what is called a secret or closed session. During a closed session, the chamber doors are closed, cameras are turned off, and the galleries are completely cleared of anyone not sworn to secrecy, not instructed in the rules of the closed session, or not essential to the session.

Closed sessions are rare and usually held only when the Senate is discussing sensitive subject matter such as information critical to national security, private communications from the president, or deliberations during impeachment trials. A senator may call for and force a closed session if the motion is seconded by at least one other member, but an agreement usually occurs beforehand.

The proceedings remain sealed indefinitely until the Senate votes to remove the injunction of secrecy. The latter identifies executive resolutions, treaties, and nominations reported out by Senate committee s and awaiting Senate floor action.

Both are updated each day the Senate is in session. The Senate uses committees and their subcommittees for a variety of purposes, including the review of bills and the oversight of the executive branch. Formally, the whole Senate appoints committee members. In practice, however, the choice of members is made by the political parties.

Generally, each party honors the preferences of individual senators, giving priority based on seniority. Each party is allocated seats on committees in proportion to its overall strength. Most committee work is performed by 16 standing committees, each of which has jurisdiction over a field such as finance or foreign relations. Each standing committee may consider, amend, and report bills that fall under its jurisdiction.

Furthermore, each standing committee considers presidential nominations to offices related to its jurisdiction. For instance, the Judiciary Committee considers nominees for judgeships, and the Foreign Relations Committee considers nominees for positions in the Department of State. Committees may block nominees and impede bills from reaching the floor of the Senate. Standing committees also oversee the departments and agencies of the executive branch.

In discharging their duties, standing committees have the power to hold hearings and to subpoena witnesses and evidence. The Senate also has several committees that are not considered standing committees.

Such bodies are generally known as select or special committees ; examples include the Select Committee on Ethics and the Special Committee on Aging. Legislation is referred to some of these committees, although the bulk of legislative work is performed by the standing committees. Committees may be established on an ad hoc basis for specific purposes; for instance, the Senate Watergate Committee was a special committee created to investigate the Watergate scandal.

Such temporary committees cease to exist after fulfilling their tasks. The Congress includes joint committees, which include members from both the Senate and the House of Representatives. Some joint committees oversee independent government bodies; for instance, the Joint Committee on the Library oversees the Library of Congress.

Other joint committees serve to make advisory reports; for example, there exists a Joint Committee on Taxation. Bills and nominees are not referred to joint committees. Hence, the power of joint committees is considerably lower than those of standing committees. Each Senate committee and subcommittee is led by a chair usually a member of the majority party.

Formerly, committee chairs were determined purely by seniority; as a result, several elderly senators continued to serve as chair despite severe physical infirmity or even senility. The chairs hold extensive powers: This last role was particularly important in mid-century, when floor amendments were thought not to be collegial. They also have considerable influence: The Senate rules and customs were reformed in the twentieth century, largely in the s.

Committee chairmen have less power and are generally more moderate and collegial in exercising it, than they were before reform. Recent criticisms of the Senate's operations object to what the critics argue is obsolescence as a result of partisan paralysis and a preponderance of arcane rules.

Bills may be introduced in either chamber of Congress. However, the Constitution's Origination Clause provides that "All bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives". Furthermore, the House of Representatives holds that the Senate does not have the power to originate appropriation bills , or bills authorizing the expenditure of federal funds. However, when the Senate originates an appropriations bill, the House simply refuses to consider it, thereby settling the dispute in practice.

The constitutional provision barring the Senate from introducing revenue bills is based on the practice of the British Parliament , in which only the House of Commons may originate such measures.

Although the Constitution gave the House the power to initiate revenue bills, in practice the Senate is equal to the House in the respect of spending. As Woodrow Wilson wrote:. The Senate's right to amend general appropriation bills has been allowed the widest possible scope. The upper house may add to them what it pleases; may go altogether outside of their original provisions and tack to them entirely new features of legislation, altering not only the amounts but even the objects of expenditure, and making out of the materials sent them by the popular chamber measures of an almost totally new character.

The approval of both houses is required for any bill, including a revenue bill, to become law. Both Houses must pass the same version of the bill; if there are differences, they may be resolved by sending amendments back and forth or by a conference committee , which includes members of both bodies. The Constitution provides several unique functions for the Senate that form its ability to "check and balance" the powers of other elements of the Federal Government.

These include the requirement that the Senate may advise and must consent to some of the president's government appointments; also the Senate must consent to all treaties with foreign governments; it tries all impeachments, and it elects the vice president in the event no person gets a majority of the electoral votes. The president can make certain appointments only with the advice and consent of the Senate.

Officials whose appointments require the Senate's approval include members of the Cabinet, heads of most federal executive agencies, ambassadors , Justices of the Supreme Court, and other federal judges. Under Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution, a large number of government appointments are subject to potential confirmation; however, Congress has passed legislation to authorize the appointment of many officials without the Senate's consent usually, confirmation requirements are reserved for those officials with the most significant final decision-making authority.

Typically, a nominee is first subject to a hearing before a Senate committee. Thereafter, the nomination is considered by the full Senate. The majority of nominees are confirmed, but in a small number of cases each year, Senate committees purposely fail to act on a nomination to block it. In addition, the president sometimes withdraws nominations when they appear unlikely to be confirmed. Because of this, outright rejections of nominees on the Senate floor are infrequent there have been only nine Cabinet nominees rejected outright in United States history.

The powers of the Senate concerning nominations are, however, subject to some constraints. For instance, the Constitution provides that the president may make an appointment during a congressional recess without the Senate's advice and consent. The recess appointment remains valid only temporarily; the office becomes vacant again at the end of the next congressional session. Nevertheless, presidents have frequently used recess appointments to circumvent the possibility that the Senate may reject the nominee.

Furthermore, as the Supreme Court held in Myers v. United States , although the Senate's advice and consent is required for the appointment of certain executive branch officials, it is not necessary for their removal. Senate passed a legally non-binding resolution against recess appointments. The Senate also has a role in ratifying treaties. The Constitution provides that the president may only "make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur" in order to benefit from the Senate's advice and consent and give each state an equal vote in the process.

However, not all international agreements are considered treaties under US domestic law, even if they are considered treaties under international law. Congress has passed laws authorizing the president to conclude executive agreements without action by the Senate. Similarly, the president may make congressional-executive agreements with the approval of a simple majority in each House of Congress, rather than a two-thirds majority in the Senate.

Neither executive agreements nor congressional-executive agreements are mentioned in the Constitution, leading some scholars such as Laurence Tribe and John Yoo [59] to suggest that they unconstitutionally circumvent the treaty-ratification process.

However, courts have upheld the validity of such agreements. The Constitution empowers the House of Representatives to impeach federal officials for "Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors" and empowers the Senate to try such impeachments.

During an impeachment trial, senators are constitutionally required to sit on oath or affirmation. Conviction requires a two-thirds majority of the senators present. A convicted official is automatically removed from office; in addition, the Senate may stipulate that the defendant be banned from holding office. No further punishment is permitted during the impeachment proceedings; however, the party may face criminal penalties in a normal court of law.

The House of Representatives has impeached sixteen officials, of whom seven were convicted. One resigned before the Senate could complete the trial. Andrew Johnson in and Bill Clinton in Both trials ended in acquittal; in Johnson's case, the Senate fell one vote short of the two-thirds majority required for conviction. Under the Twelfth Amendment , the Senate has the power to elect the vice president if no vice presidential candidate receives a majority of votes in the Electoral College.

The Twelfth Amendment requires the Senate to choose from the two candidates with the highest numbers of electoral votes. Electoral College deadlocks are rare. The Senate has only broken a deadlock once; in , it elected Richard Mentor Johnson.

The House elects the president if the Electoral College deadlocks on that choice. The following are published by the Senate Historical Office. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Seal of the U. Upper house of the United States Congress. President of the Senate. Mike Pence R Since January 20, Orrin Hatch R Since January 6, Chuck Schumer D Since January 3, John Cornyn R Since January 3, Dick Durbin D Since January 3, History of the United States Senate. Current members by seniority by class.

Party leadership of the United States Senate. Executive session Morning business. Quorum Quorum call Salaries. Saxbe fix Seal Holds. Senatorial courtesy Standing Rules. Senate office buildings Dirksen Hart Russell. List of United States Senate elections. Constitution of the United States Law Taxation. Presidential elections Midterm elections Off-year elections. Democratic Republican Third parties. Seniority in the United States Senate.

Clay pigeon floor procedure. Closed sessions of the United States Senate. United States congressional committee. Current members of the United States Senate. Retrieved October 4, The Yale Law Journal. Berke September 12, The New York Times. Friedman March 30, A Reappraisal of the Seventeenth Amendment, —".

Agenda Content and Senate Partisanship, ". Article 1, Section 1 ". Retrieved March 22, Notes of the Secret Debates of the Federal Convention of Archived from the original on November 23, Archived from the original on November 1, Retrieved September 17, Retrieved November 17, United States Printing Office. Retrieved November 13, Retrieved 20 April Massachusetts Great and General Court.

Archived from the original on May 28, Retrieved October 2, Retrieved June 19, Retrieved July 11, Retrieved November 10, Retrieved February 8, Gold, Senate Procedure and Practice , p. Every member, when he speaks, shall address the chair, standing in his place, and when he has finished, shall sit down.

Lazing on a Senate afternoon". Voting in the Senate". Retrieved April 11, Zelizer, On Capitol Hill describes this process; one of the reforms is that seniority within the majority party can now be bypassed, so that chairs do run the risk of being deposed by their colleagues. See in particular p.

Archived from the original on August 10, Retrieved January 1, The Invention of the United States Senate , p. A Study in American Politics , pp. According to the Library of Congress , the Constitution provides the origination requirement for revenue bills, whereas tradition provides the origination requirement for appropriation bills.

Text common to all printings or "editions"; in Papers of Woodrow Wilson it is Vol. Retrieved November 20, ; Ritchie, Congress p. Retrieved November 20, The Senate of the United States: A Bicentennial History Krieger, The Senators, the Representatives and the Governors: Brady and Mathew D. Party, Process, and Political Change in Congress: The Years of Lyndon Johnson. Master of the Senate. Press of Kansas, Politics and Policy in the th and th Congresses ; massive, highly detailed summary of Congressional activity, as well as major executive and judicial decisions; based on Congressional Quarterly Weekly Report and the annual CQ almanac.

Congressional Quarterly Congress and the Nation: Congress and the Nation: Breaking the Heart of the World: Woodrow Wilson and the Fight for the League of Nations. Congress and Its Members , 6th ed. Legislative procedure, informal practices, and member information Gould, Lewis L. The Most Exclusive Club: Hubris and Heroism in the U. Senate, — Sharpe, The Road to Mass Democracy: Original Intent and the Seventeenth Amendment.

Popular elections of senators Lee, Frances E. Sizing Up the Senate: The Unequal Consequences of Equal Representation. MacNeil, Neil and Richard A. Oxford University Press, The United States Senate Years, — From Obstruction to Moderation: The Transformation of Senate Conservatism, — Press Mann, Robert. The Walls of Jericho: Harcourt Brace, Ritchie, Donald A.

Main Topics

Privacy Policy

The Senate is composed of senators, each of whom represents a single state in its entirety, with each state being equally represented by two senators, regardless of its population, serving staggered terms of six years; with 50 states currently in the Union, there are U.S. Senators.

Privacy FAQs

The length of terms in state senates in the 50 American state senates is either two years or four years. Senators in 31 states have a four-year term. Senators in 12 states have a two-year term. Senators in seven states (Arkansas, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey and Texas) have.

About Our Ads

Oklahoma Legislature: six two-year terms for House members (twelve years) and three four-year terms for Senate members (twelve years). Once term-limited in one house, a legislator cannot be elected to the other. Senators in Class II were elected to office in the November general election, unless they took their seat through appointment or special election. Their terms run from the beginning of the th Congress on January 6, to the end of the th Congress on January 3,

Cookie Info

The US Constitution, Article I, Sections 2 and 3, sets the term lengths and qualifications for US Senators and Congressmen. Article I sets the term of office for members of th e US House of Representatives at two years (Section . Assembly officers include the Speaker, Speaker pro Tempore, Chief Clerk, and Sergeant-at-Arms. Senate officers include the President pro Tempore, Secretary of the Senate, .